The useful question is not which image format wins in every situation. It is which export meets the needs of this image and its destination. A product photograph, a screenshot of small text and a transparent logo have different failure modes.

Start with the receiving system

Before exporting a store catalogue, inspect the upload rules of the actual store, marketplace or publishing system. A supported web-browser format is not automatically accepted by every product feed, email workflow or desktop application. Test one representative item all the way to its final display before converting a whole catalogue.

A short decision map

  • Photograph for a website: compare JPEG and WebP exports at the intended display size. Inspect visible quality and bytes rather than assuming an identical quality number means the same output.
  • Screenshot or graphic with fine text: start with a lossless candidate such as PNG. Check text edges at normal viewing size. If trying another format, compare the actual result.
  • Transparent raster artwork: use an alpha-capable export such as PNG or WebP when the destination accepts it. JPEG needs a deliberate background.
  • Editable brand artwork: keep the original design file separately. A raster delivery copy is not a substitute for the master.

The order of work matters

Keep a master, decide the crop, resize a copy to the intended delivery dimensions, then export candidates. This order avoids spending time compressing pixels that will be discarded later. Do not upscale a small source and describe the result as recovered detail.

For an ecommerce product, compare the product's visible scale across the set, the padding, the crop and the background. Format consistency alone will not fix a catalogue in which one bag fills the frame and another looks tiny.

Use a small comparison record

For each candidate, record filename, dimensions, bytes and where you checked it. Inspect a fine edge, a smooth background and any small text. Choose a deliverable that looks acceptable in the final page, then keep the record beside the source. This is a proposed review method, not a compression benchmark or a claimed AGMAD test result.

Transparency should be checked against the destination background. A preview on white can hide an unwanted white fringe. If the publishing system generates its own thumbnails, inspect those thumbnails too; a correct original can still be cropped badly downstream.

What this guide corrects

The previous article called one format the smallest or best without a representative comparison and promoted unverified tool features. Those blanket claims have been removed. WebP supports several encoding modes, JPEG commonly serves lossy photographs, and PNG provides lossless raster storage. The best delivery decision still depends on the input and receiving system.

For conversion limits, read JPEG to PNG: what changes. For crop planning, read our aspect-ratio workflow. AGMAD tool experiments are listed separately in the Lab.

Format reference: MDN's image-format guide. No percentage saving or universal performance result is implied.